
| For a moment, I wish appearances didn't matter. I wish I could simply master the law and the evidence and do my job. |
By power chair, I zoom toward the Four Corners of Law, the
old heart of Charleston's legal community. It's the first day of a federal jury trial,
and I'm a lawyer for the plaintiff.
In over a decade of law practice, I've had very few jury trials. Usually we conduct
discovery, go to a judge with a few motions, and the case is resolved one way or
the other. But this one is going to trial, and I'll be the first lawyer to address
the jury.
I'm nervous, but I've suited up for the occasion. I can't wear those woman-lawyer
suits you see on TV, but my raw silk turquoise dress drapes nicely around the curves
of my back. I'm wearing my best black shoes. They're velvet, and cost six dollars
at the local hippie store. And, of course, serious jewelry--a simple gold bracelet,
pearl earrings, a sapphire ring. It's my kind of power dressing. Everyone will know
I'm a lawyer. They'll know I'm a force to be reckoned with.
There's a lot riding on the opening. Research shows that most jurors are convinced--or
not--during opening statements. I've heard hints that I'm the wrong person for this
job. It's an ADA case, and my client was fired, she says, because she told her boss
she'd need back surgery. The problem is that, compared to me, she doesn't look like
she has a disability. In fact, she looks great in a suit. The company lawyer will
surely tell the jury there's no way this plaintiff can file an ADA lawsuit when there's
nothing wrong with her. How do I convince them otherwise?
I stop obsessing and enjoy the ride. I know every bump in the slate sidewalks,
every gap in the old bricks. I know when to slam full speed ahead, when to slow down,
when to dodge. As I get closer, I merge with a stream of lawyers and clients striding
on legs from downtown offices to court. I flawlessly navigate the challenging terrain
without clipping any of them. I'm good. I belong in this world. Nobody can mess with
me.
I stop for a line of cars. Beside me an elderly Black lady waits at the bus stop
and looks me over. I'm used to being gawked at, but this is different. She's looking
at my clothes, my jewelry, my "look," and her smile is openly appreciative.
I nod at her the way we nod at one another in downtown Charleston.
"You look so beautiful," she says.
I give her the classic aw-shucks smile.
"You look just like a Doll Baby!"
A Doll Baby? Not a tough, terrifying litigator?
My smile freezes and I say, "Thank you, ma'am." She means well. And
in a flash I know there is a certain Doll Baby factor at work. My body is undeniably
small and ragdoll-floppy. And, against the vivid turquoise dress, the extreme Whiteness
of my face and hands must look like--well, porcelain.
The traffic clears and I cross the street. I have one short block to get focused.
I'm jumpy when the judge calls for plaintiff's opening, but I find the spot where
I can meet the eyes of all 12 jurors. As I begin the expected formalities, I find
the rituals restore a sense of confidence. Echoed on marble and mahogany, my voice
comes back strong, clear, and just genteel enough. I'm ready to confront the issues.
I explain about invisible disabilities. I review the evidence. Formality gives way
to folksiness. One by one, the faces show understanding, acceptance.
As I thank them for their attention, I'm conscious of 12 faces looking at nothing
but me. Clearly, they're responding not only to my words, but also to my visible
persona--to the tiny woman in a wheelchair, wearing gorgeous fabrics and precious
metals and stones. A different kind of lawyer.
I turn back to the plaintiff's table and I know those two dozen eyes are watching
the arc I make, like a skater, as my tires etch the plush carpeting. For a moment,
I wish appearances didn't matter. I wish I could simply master the law and the evidence
and do my job. But then I look back at the jury. They're still with me, and I'm glad.
The Doll Baby has spoken.
Harriet McBryde Johnson practices law in Charleston, S.C. and presently chairs
the City of Charleston Democratic Party.
ster001