When an Accessible Hotel ‘Reservation’ Doesn’t Guarantee Anything


White man using power wheelchair, looking up at street sign with "handicapped crossing" set in parking lot

After nine hours driving across the southwest in my packed minivan, I could almost feel the hotel mattress by the time I rolled into the lobby of the Phoenix Hampton Inn. My achy shoulders and rumbling stomach subsided, knowing that after a week and almost 2,000 miles of driving, it was time for my Arizona vacation to begin. Five days in the sun, six baseball games and no responsibilities — I’d been looking forward to my first post-pandemic trip since I booked everything almost four months earlier.

I handed the receptionist my ID and credit card to confirm the reservation and watched her face change as she stared at her computer screen. I could feel my stomach and shoulders starting to groan again. Something was wrong.

“I’m sorry, sir, but we don’t have any rooms with roll-in showers available.”

“But I reserved one almost three months ago. I have the confirmation number right here. I even called to double-confirm it two days ago.”

“Our rooms with roll-in showers are occupied tonight, so …”

“That’s why I reserved one three months ago. I have a five-night reservation and I can’t shower without a roll-in.”

“I’m sorry, but we can’t hold those rooms, as we have to give them out if people need them.”

“I don’t think you understand what a reservation is,” I said, my frustration fully visible. The next 10 minutes felt like a humorless Seinfeld sketch. I tried to explain what I thought was a simple concept and she looked at me like I was from another planet.

If you’ve traveled at all as a wheelchair user, chances are you’ve found yourself in the same situation: denied the accommodations you need despite going beyond the letter of the law. Embarrassing, dehumanizing and rage-inducing don’t begin to describe the mixture of emotions swirling through your brain — because you know that despite having the moral and rational high ground, ineptitude and ableism are going to leave you with nowhere to stay and no satisfactory resolution.

I kept trying to explain how unacceptable the situation was, in hopes she would at least help me find somewhere to spend the night. A small part of me also wanted to make her feel the same hurt I did.  When it became clear that neither was attainable, I simply gave up.

Endless Frustration, No One to Help

Finding an affordable room with a roll-in shower for an extended stay is never easy. Doing so at 9 p.m. in a town full of spring breakers and elderly sun chasers adds a whole other level of intrigue. It’s exactly why I’d reserved the room months earlier. I ended up having to split the nights between two different hotels and paying almost $700 more than I had planned.

When I finally got home, I vowed to do anything I could to ensure no other disabled person had to endure what I did. My first call was to the property manager. She tried to give me the same spiel the receptionist had and eventually hung up on me. I calmly called back and explained I simply wanted to help her fix the problem. She gave me an 800 number and promised they had the power to address the situation. The number was dead.

Hampton Inn is one of Hilton’s many hotel brands, so I submitted a formal complaint through the company’s website and blindly emailed several Hilton employees I found on LinkedIn. None of the LinkedIn inquiries received responses, but I did receive well-formatted emails from Ankit, Mohit and Jaishiv in Hilton’s complaint response team apologizing but telling me they were unable to call me to discuss further.

One person who did return my phone call was Assistant U.S. Attorney Lauren DeBruicker. We’ve profiled DeBruicker in New Mobility before, and she is one of a handful of wheelchair users kicking ass and taking names in the Department of Justice. She turned me on to the DOJ’s revised ADA regulations around accessible lodging which clearly laid out exactly the arguments I’d futilely made to the receptionist and manager. Most significantly: When a reservation is made for an accessible guest room, the specific accessible guest room reserved must be held for the reserving customer, and the room must be removed from the reservation system.

As simple as that seems, Hilton properties have a history of struggling to comply. In 2010, in response to a DOJ complaint that around 900 of their properties had failed to meet ADA standards, Hilton agreed to physically bring these properties up to ADA standards and fix their reservation system so disabled guests could actually get the rooms they reserved.

I’m happy to acknowledge that Hilton has made lots of progress around accessibility in the last 13 years (we recognized its Home2 Suites brand as the best chain for wheelchair users), but my experience — and the similar experiences I’ve heard from many others — shows how much work remains to be done.

white male power wheelchair user and nondisabled white man posing in front of empty baseball field.
After countless hours of frustration and $700 in extra expenses, Ian Ruder was able to continue his vacation to baseball spring training.

Finally a Resolution

After a month of emails and calls producing no results, I was on the verge of giving up. The fading prospect of corporate accountability was losing to the daily demands of quad-life. Then, while I was about to dig into my Sunday breakfast, my phone rang with an unknown Texas number.

On the other end was an executive ambassador from Hilton’s customer relations team. Over a 15-minute conversation she apologized for what I had gone through and relayed the conversations she’d had with the regional director of sales who oversees the Hampton Inn where I stayed. She explained that through their conversation, the director of sales discovered an issue in their inventory and reservation system that prevented them from appropriately reserving rooms with specific accessible features. She promised me the issue was being fixed and would not affect any future disabled travelers.

Without booking another room at the same hotel, there’s no easy way to see if these promised changes have been implemented. The optimist in me hopes so. And the pessimist in me takes solace in knowing that speaking up about the issue, I prevented the local operators from sweeping it under the rug with no accountability.

As disabled people, we shouldn’t have to do extra work for the same access and benefits the rest of society enjoys, but unfortunately, we are often faced with doing so or accepting discrimination. If a hotel or other business has discriminated against you, or you think they are in violation of the ADA, I encourage you to submit a claim at ADA.gov.

DeBruicker knows how hard it can be to find the time and energy to pursue complaints, but she assures me the complaints are seen by the DOJ and often lead to investigations and lawsuits. “It’s a pretty simple way to say something,” she says. “Honestly, if all of us reported everything, it would probably flood the system, but it would make an impact.”


Submit Your Hotel Discrimination Story

If you’re reading this before June 30, 2023, and you have a hotel horror story in which you didn’t get the room you reserved, couldn’t make the reservation you needed or were flat out discriminated against, a powerful disability coalition wants to hear from you. Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, Paralyzed Veterans of America, the National Disability Rights Network, The Arc, and the law firm of Fox & Robertson are gathering stories to present in a brief to the Supreme Court, and have created a simple online form to collect incident reports. Fill it out and help hold hoteliers accountable.


Support New Mobility

Wait! Before you wander off to other parts of the internet, please consider supporting New Mobility. For more than three decades, New Mobility has published groundbreaking content for active wheelchair users. We share practical advice from wheelchair users across the country, review life-changing technology and demand equity in healthcare, travel and all facets of life. But none of this is cheap, easy or profitable. Your support helps us give wheelchair users the resources to build a fulfilling life.

29 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
RollinPositive
RollinPositive
2 years ago

The title of the article is totally misleading and truly discourages people in our community from traveling

Had you done a little more due diligence you will have been fine

1st make sure your talking with someone on property then ask for the GM

Better yet email them so you have a digital footprint

Ask them to seen you pics and video of the room and bathroom make sure it works for you

Then have the GM block the room for your arrival

Email them a week before to make sure everything is fine and on track

I live in the area and that is a busy time with spring training etc

If a hotel will not work with you at the local level email the CEO for help guarantee at that level people listen

Jason
Jason
2 years ago
Reply to  RollinPositive

Your premise that “Had you done a little more due diligence you will have been fine” is just flat incorrect. I’ve reserved rooms directly with the hotel (800 number reservations lines do not work. The operator will say it’s available and it isn’t) weeks ahead, called them two days before my trip and then again the day before to guarantee I get the room. I always have my email confirmation in hand. The manager isn’t always available and will not call you back. So that’s out. Then, I get there and guess what? No room. We even stopped at one in Santa Fe, NM and have been told the room’s being cleaned and it’s not ready. We informed them we’d go eat and return. We left our name, showed them the confirmation number and left. In the interim, they gave the room away. And it was early in the day. So I ask you…what more “due diligence” should I have done?

GNXMan
GNXMan
2 years ago
Reply to  RollinPositive

Um, thats exactly what he did and they still gave his room away. Thats the point!

WILFRED
WILFRED
2 years ago
Reply to  RollinPositive

He did more than enough due diligence! Think about it Take the need for special accommodations out of the equation and I bet there were other people w/reservations who were similarly unceremoniously bumped/had thier reservations disregarded.

Jon
Jon
2 years ago
Reply to  RollinPositive

After reading this reply I knew who the commenter was before even reading the name, because unfortunately it’s the same response across other message boards as well where he minimizes people’s experiences and instead chastises them for not doing enough. I’m not sure he even read the article, which stated he spoke with the hotel 2 days prior to confirm his reservation. The accountability should be on the hotel, and not the guest’s responsibility to make it a full time job guaranteeing their reservation.

Bruce Sinclair
Bruce Sinclair
2 years ago
Reply to  RollinPositive

You obviously don’t travel much or don’t have specific accessibility requirements when you make such a misinformed and obnoxious comment. This happens to me at least once a year. I confirm my bookings with the local hotel at the time of booking and a couple of days ahead of arriving.

Ann Marie Jones
Ann Marie Jones
2 years ago

This kind of crap goes on all the time. When you’re complaints go nowhere that’s when you inform them that they will be hearing from your attorney.

GNXMan
GNXMan
2 years ago

This crap happens all the time. Or just as bad, you get an “accessible room” and its pathetic. Folks think that ADA law has made “accessible rooms” the same, but not so! There a a wide variation of ADA implementations from room to room! Many are just plain stupid.

Julie Collins
Julie Collins
2 years ago

I believe the same accountability is required in the cruise industry. We sailed with Royal Caribbean in March 2023, and I had the worst experience of my life. I use a power wheelchair. All crew members referred to it as my “scooter”. Some even suggested that I get up and walk to our dining table and down the gangplank at the ports! The humiliation of having a 45° or more angle to disembark required 3-4 crew members holding me back in my chair to keep from toppling both me and the chair over. Getting back on board I had absolutely no choice but to get out of my chair and crawl/creep up the incline so that crew could get my chair up the sharp incline. There was no other option because there weren’t enough crew members to lift it up. The resulting pain was excruciating and caused me take to bed for several hours afterwards. CocoCay was a joke. There are no accessible pathways to the waters edge and unless you travel with an able-bodied person, there’s no way to use the manual beach wheelchairs. No crew will assist. Ever the optimist, I decided the pool would do, as they had a lift. There were no instructions on how to use it, and no staff members to explain or assist. While RCL advertises that there is at least one pool lift per ship – there was no lift on Jewel of the Seas. I’m the only person I’ve ever known who never got their new bathing suit wet on a Caribbean cruise.

I am aware that the cruise lines are not responsible for ADA compliance at the ports and cities they visit. They are, however, responsible for embarkation and debarkation. The angles of the gangplanks can be easily resolved by adapting them to reduce angles to the dock surface.

There were 4 accessible excursions on our 8 day cruise. When you read the descriptions you will note that they don’t guarantee your travel companions can accompany you. Some “accessible “ excursions still require that you be able to walk short distances and/or go up and down stairs. Don’t advertise them as accessible then! We opted not to take a chance.

The stateroom that was listed as accessible was super small for my power chair to maneuver with ease. The bathroom, however, was nicely appointed and the mounted shower chair was perfectly situated for use of the shower head. We were told the room would have a queen bed and a pull out sofa. It had a king bed and no pull out sofa. The room attendant suggested my 72 year old husband (who walks with a cane) could climb up the bunk ladder. I said that was out of the question and asked her to separate the king. It took 2 days before she actually separated the king into 2 twin beds. I had to ask for it 3 times.

There’s much more I could list, but this gives you a rough idea of my experience. My complaint letter went unheeded for a long time. Ultimately I got a “too bad, so sad” letter and they denied my request for a refund.

We won’t be cruising again. We saved up for 16 years and that money was not well spent.

Kristy
Kristy
2 years ago

Did Hilton at least compensate you for the additional costs you had to incur because of their total failure to follow the law?

Janine Hunt-Jackson
Janine Hunt-Jackson
2 years ago
Reply to  Ian Ruder

I didn’t even get that! Too bad the survey/reply for stories due by June 30 didn’t arrive in my email until today, August 1st! I have a couple of “lovely” stories about my June/July stays in supposedly accessible Wyndham hotels!

Nancy K. Powell
Nancy K. Powell
2 years ago

Same here!

Benjamin Elstad
Benjamin Elstad
2 years ago

I’m sure this happens with other hotel chains as well, and maybe even more specifically with individual hotels. I typically stay with Marriott affiliated hotels. I have had outstanding experiences, even when confronted with obstacles. I stayed at a W in Atlanta, GA while doing drivers training at the Shepherd Center. When I got in my room, the bed was a platform bed. The front wheels of my lift would not go under the bed. They sent up a maintenance supervisor, who was very compassionate. Within an hour, he had gone to the local hardware store, purchased what he needed to raise the bed enough for my lift to work, and the issue was fixed. I had an amazing stay for the week. I’ve had other situations where the folding bench that is in the shower blocked me from using my personal shower chair. Again, maintenance comes up and either removes or modifies the shower bench. I suppose I’ve been very fortunate. I understand not everyone is.

KLD
KLD
2 years ago

You are lucky. Have had bad experiences with Courtyard by Marriott in California, where they weren’t even in compliance with CA accessibility laws more strict than the ADA.

Bruce Sinclair
Bruce Sinclair
2 years ago

The latest problem with Marriott is they have upgraded many of their hotels with new beds that are too high for me to transfer from my chair. I have started asking for someone to measure the height of the bed and they are usually happy to do this.

Kristi Saul
Kristi Saul
2 years ago

I’ve had this happen three in the past 6 months with Marriott hotels. This is discrimination. It happened occasionally precovid but seems more frequent now. My situation is that on both occasions they were able to at least find an accessible room on the property but they were clearly rooms that were not intended to be used. They were poor repair with toilets not working, blinds broken, towel racks off the wall. I would be interested in speaking to the author of the article and discussing organizing a class action suit. Not because I want money but I want this discrimination to stop!

Amy E.
Amy E.
2 years ago
Reply to  David

LOL! Dying.

Amy E.
Amy E.
2 years ago

#ThePowerOfTheShower
I think a social media campaign should be started #ThePowerOfTheShower
I won’t even begin to tell my horror stories because I have so many times (to the ADA, attorneys, politicians, etc.) and they never are met with action. Social Media has become the soap box for the disabled, whether it is due to mobility, accessibility or for many other reasons. Let’s change something.

KLD
KLD
2 years ago
Reply to  Amy E.

It’s not just the shower though. Accessible rooms should NOT have platform beds that you cannot get a lift under. That is not specified in the ADA regulations though (although many don’t know that it has been in CA law for a number of years).

EFH
EFH
2 years ago
Reply to  Amy E.

So true! My husband has a progressive muscle disease – Inclusion body myositis (IBM) – he will eventually need a hoyer lift to get in and out of bed / bathroom etc and we are already feeling like travel will be nearly impossible at that point
So discouraging
Another IBM patient we met several yrs ago told us he had written to our so called representatives in DC – Elizabeth Warren, Ed Markey detailing his experiences and how inadequate the ADA laws are…he either got no response or a form letter in response! It’s not dehumanizing enough to be disabled but to be ignored by officials that are supposed to assist you is a travesty.
I’m glad you got something’ in the form of 2 vouchers but seriously? That does NOT make up for what you went through!!!

Bob Amelio
Bob Amelio
2 years ago

The big problem at hotels are pool lifts. If they have one either they don’t work or aren’t independently operable.

Bob
Bob
2 years ago

I would have done 1 more thing. When the desk clerk said that they couldn’t hold the room if someone wanted it, I would have asked 1 simple question. If all of your rooms were prebooked for tonight and someone walked in and asked for a room would you have bumped a reservation and given them one? Of course they would not have, so why did they do it for an accessible room?

Dan
Dan
2 years ago

I just read this article. As a W/C user for 37 years now I can tell you a lot pf horror stories even before ADA.

I never use any 800, 888 or the companies national numbers and always contact the property direct, get names, prices and email conformation.

I can’t say I have seen it all because if I did I would be kidding myself, being kind.

Twice I have been appeased to a luxury suite they keep on hold for the powers to be and they were not accessible. And they thought they were doing me/us a favor…

cjshs
cjshs
2 years ago

Ian,
I applaud you for the way in which you addressed this all too familiar issue. A two day voucher?!? This doesn’t begin to address the insensitive discriminatory business model in effect many of us encounter on a daily basis. I am glad that even with the unnecessary stress filled start of your vacation, you were able to attend the tryouts!!! Thank you for sharing your experience and actionable steps to consider using when such occasions arise.
Carla Steinbuchel

Carrie
Carrie
2 years ago

Hampton Inn Pasadena/Arcadia told me on June 30th they don’t guarantee an accessible room with roll-in shower. Said it would be given away if someone arrived before me or booked a longer stay than my one night.

Kay
Kay
2 years ago

What can we do if this has happened after June 2023? I experienced this over the weekend and need to be sure to get the right people’s attention. I won’t be back at at that hotel, but I don’t want anyone lese to experience such a nightmare.